✦Your Birthday. Our History. Everybody's Story.✦Hosted by Addae Olamina✦A new conversation every calendar day✦Fact-checked through the Library of Congress✦Same date. Different stories.✦The past, freshly told.✦Your Birthday. Our History. Everybody's Story.✦Hosted by Addae Olamina✦A new conversation every calendar day✦Fact-checked through the Library of Congress✦Same date. Different stories.✦The past, freshly told.
Celestial ephemeris chart over deep navy
Back to all episodes
1889: North & South Dakota Enter the Union
November 2, 1889Politics

1889: North & South Dakota Enter the Union

One territory. Two states. Was America really better off with two Dakotas?

Featured birthday guest

Marcus Vance

From Fargo, ND

"Growing up in North Dakota, everybody told us South Dakota got statehood first by three seconds. Turns out President Harrison hid the documents!"

Birthday memory: My 30th birthday campfire under the huge open sky in Theodore Roosevelt National Park.

Participating scholar

Dr. Eleanor Vance

Professor of Western American History, UND

Providing historical context, primary-document vetting, and intellectual substance during today's lively discussion.

Are you a historian? Apply to join an episode

Historical overview

On November 2, 1889, Dakota Territory was divided and simultaneously admitted to the Union as the 39th and 40th states. We uncover the high-stakes railroad lobbying, political rivalries, and settler disputes that split Dakota into two separate powerhouses.

Wait… that happened today?

"President Benjamin Harrison intentionally covered the signatures with paper so neither state could claim seniority. To this day, nobody knows which document was signed first!"

Questions explored in this episode

  • 1.Why did party leaders in Washington prefer two states instead of one unified Dakota?
  • 2.How did railroad companies influence the location of state capitals in Bismarck and Pierre?
  • 3.What cultural differences still divide North and South Dakotans today?

The big question

"If Dakota remained one single state today, how would it change American Senate political power?"

Select an option to register your vote. · 1,043 listeners have weighed in.

Primary sources & archival references

Dakota Territory Statehood Records (1889)National Archives
Harrison's Presidential Shuffler MemoirLibrary of Congress